Vinarto: I'm torn between 3 and 4. 4 because of the lighting, which makes it look more professional. But 3 because the witch-hunter control panel is all in the mind, it's not physical, therefore it shouldn't cast light.

Toryu-Mau: ... 4, M8. >):^]

DOOMGUY11: I want 5
Jk 4 for me

hypeonthemic: i prefer 3

Jakobqasadilla: 3

scoopski: gonna answer with 3

AMKitsune: I'd also say 3 or 4, simply because the more recognisable the icon can be at a glance, the better.
Although it also has to be said that the icon might very well be too dark. Imagine one of these icons on a desktop along with a bunch of other programs and files. Most of the icons on my desktop are either very bright, colourful or have a balanced mix of dark and bright areas. Something so overwhelmingly dark may stand out against everything else on a person's desktop, and not in a good way. Also I measured the height of these and they seem to come out at 50px tall. I had a quick look and that seems to be a little bit larger than the closest icon size in windows.
https://www.creativefreedom.co.uk/icon-designers-blog/windows-7-icon-sizes/
If you're making your icon as an aliased pixel art thing, you might need to either remake it multiple times to best fit the different icon sizes a user could choose from, or accept that any automatic resizing done by the computer will likely make the icon look a bit shit.

So two things to take away. Be aware of luminosity compared to other desktop icons and the fact that icons have standard resolutions. Hope that helped.

Toxic: @AMKitsune: Thanks, that was actually pretty helpful. The new ones I made are now all 256x256, 4bit for compatibility on all desktops, and significantly brighter. I also went ahead and made the border a bit smoother for the resolution and it actually came out nice I think.
So this:

Turns into this:

That's zoomed in quite a bit, so if you want to see it regularly go here.

@Vinarto: You had a good point, so I redid the shadows to seem a bit more natural. I hope this is better

AMKitsune: @Toxic: Looking really good . One last thing I've noticed though. The background blends in with her cloak quite a bit when viewed from a distance. Perhaps shift it's hue a touch to better differentiate if from the foreground? I don't know, just a thought. See how it looks and go from there.

OgTariq: so wait, im confused is he not working on this anymore???

KuroNeko: Cute happy Kat

APayne1776: Adorable

Dominik: We need more pictures of her smiling, so cuuuute

Rick2tails: this is cute! :)

Jadezzar: Must.Hug

Vidiotdragon: Well aint she precious.

KuroNeko: Sorry Katia, now that you have accepted his help he is your ancestor too now.

Kazerad: Aggy makes this picture.

Dominik: Meh, they are all just jealous

Zargothrax: Skeleton ears are a must have for cats to remain cute after they depart

AMKitsune: @Zargothrax: What if they all just wear cat ear headbands under their hoods?

AwfulAspiringArtist: Oops, forgot to change the file name. Oh well. To make up for my complete ineptitude towards art, I've learned (just barely) the intro for Impending Doom. I haven't fully or properly translated it because I'm currently learning Divine's Lament from Divnity OS:2, however I plan to learn this amazing piece after that. Hope you enjoy what I've got so far

SlashSeven: it fascinates

DOOMGUY11: I got but one important question:
Is there a heavy metal version? If not I'll make one because I love this piecr!

OgTariq: better than Beethoven

PermanentFace: Ha! I get it!

damrok4321: So
this day finally arrived
Final day of the challenge

damrok4321: aaand it ends with Katia being sick of that
eh this been quite a trip, it sure helped me to improve

Zargothrax: Looks like she has a hairball coming up

Dominik: Propably some flashbacks from last voyage

OgTariq: noooooo! its over well you did a great job and i really enjoyed each and every single one

Rick2tails: whoa! now thats BAD ASS!!

mercrantos: WHIPPED CREAM BULLETS

DarthVader: Amazing! Make this into s movie! Haha lol!

Raydio: This is epic

FrscoThaProducer: Loving the detail on the shoes

OgTariq: instead of Pedro being a banana hes a pineapple now

OgTariq: is it me or is if getting hot in here

no like literally its 90 degrees outside

damrok4321: Im melting rn

Dominik: I literally have to sleep like her partner (shirtless) to not die from temperature...

damrok4321: 24th day of challenge

OgTariq: i think she discovered herself on E621, (but for real though dont go to that website or else you'll be mortified of certain things you might fine

Lurci: Being a star in the furry fandom can be quit uncomfortable, even for her.

Dominik: @OgTariq: I wish i could forget what i saw there...

Vinarto: @Jim_North: Oh, not much, just... YOUR SOUL!

KuroNeko:

vsauce4: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=x9flRh5Ytto

Sashimi: @vsauce4: TIME!

Sashimi: So just how much water does one receive in this purchase?

Zargothrax: Didn't see this coming

Dominik: @Vinarto: Fine, o'dim, this time you got me. Where do i have to sign?

fastolaf: how much for your toilet water, katia?

APayne1776: Ummm... No

AMKitsune: SCARY CARD? Oh boy, that's the best kind of CARD!
@fastolaf: Ahem *adjusts monocle*, I think you'll find the proper term to be 'eau de toilette'. Much more dignified and marketable XD